Author: info@amberhawk.com

When are facial recognition systems, used for law enforcement, not subject to a data protection regime?

This blog concerns the information processed by the facial recognition system used by South Wales Police (SWP) in the recent judicial review case (see references).  In summary, I don’t think the Data Protection Act 2018 (DPA2018) applies to most of this processing because the information processed by the system is not personal data. This is not the conclusion the Court arrived at in its recent judgment (the “SWP judgment”); the blog explains what this judgement missed and why its conclusions

Read article

Judicial review: how did the Government decide that the immigration exemption was in “the general public interest”?

The immigration exemption in Schedule 2 (paragraph 4) of the Data Protection Act 2018 (DPA2018) has always been controversial; it is subject to a judicial review by the High Court, in London, on July 23 & 24. The controversy arises because an exemption that was not needed by the immigration authorities under the DPA1984, nor under the DPA1998, has nothing to do with crime, tax, any compulsory court order, any mandatory disclosure requirement or national security issue. However, suddenly this exemption became an urgent necessity

Read article

Consent for access to phones in some rape cases implies that such access is not necessary for law enforcement

This blog shows that the current furore concerning access to a rape victim’s phone, relying on consent of a rape victim, sits uneasily with a data protection analysis.  I also point out that there appears to be three forms of “consent” floating around in the GDPR/Data Protection Act 2018 (“DPA2018”) framework. First of all, the relevant part of the DPA2018 to consider is the law enforcement elements, as access to the victim’s phone is by the police or prosecutors in relation

Read article

Amberhawk wins a Cyber Security Challenge UK prize – but it has been returned

{Blog changed on 2nd April due to the threat of legal action by the Homeland Security Department of USA} Amberhawk is pleased to announce that it has won a Cyber Security Challenge UK competition for the best idea in 2019 (so far) to prevent cyber-crime in the young.  Our idea involves enhanced parental responsibility, increased awareness of computer crime and teaches children under the age of ten about the dangers from hacking.  No special technology or software is needed. To

Read article

Do the DPA2018 exemptions work properly?

Do you know what? I am beginning to wonder whether some of the exemptions in Schedule 2 of the DPA2018 work as they should. So, if you disagree with the following analysis please make a counter argument. First, I think all the exemptions that are constructed using the use of the word “processed” provide a lawful basis for one controller to disclose personal data to another controller for the purposes/reasons identified in the exemption.  In this way, the exemptions permit a

Read article

Questions concerning the DPA1998 haunt the UK’s approach to GDPR implementation and threatens adequacy

Yesterday, the Secretary of State for Business was caught out misleading the public and Parliament concerning Brexit.  He evidently authorised a secret, multi-million pound bung to Nissan so that it maintained car production at its current level in Sunderland, post Brexit.  Sad to say, such secrecy by Ministers is rather commonplace with respect to Brexit and data protection. The evidence for this assertion comes from my latest FOI request to the European Commission (see references). For instance, consider the Prime

Read article

Draft Brexit Data Protection Regulations would undermine adequacy determination for the UK

Belated Happy New Year. One thing can be certain following the recent Brexit Parliamentary shenanigans.  The UK will eventually choose from: (a) a hard Brexit; (b) a deferred Brexit; (c) a Brexit perhaps softer than Mrs May’s defeated Brexit, or (d) no Brexit.  As most options involve Brexit, the approach the Government has adopted to align Brexit with the GDPR is important. The draft “Data Protection, Privacy and Electronic Communications (Amendments etc) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019” (the “Regulations”) were tabled

Read article

Draft Withdrawal Agreement does not guarantee frictionless free flow of personal data from European Union

How do you think Brexit is going? When you ask this question, most people shake their heads, or utter an expletive or refer to sayings that contain words such as “brewery” and “organise”. Anyway, the draft Withdrawal Agreement has been made public and there has been quite a lot of data protection commentary saying that the UK does not need to worry about transfers of personal data from the European Union (EU) after March 29 (assuming the Agreement keeps its current

Read article

Is the ICO’s view of “lawful processing” under the GDPR wrong?

What makes processing “lawful” under the GDPR? The Information Commissioner (ICO) has stated that the word “lawfulness” has general application, as it did under the previous Data Protection Act (DPA1998). If my analysis is correct, this view is wrong; I think "lawfulness" is now limited in meaning to "compliance with the GDPR or DPA2018". If so, there is a significant risk that the level of the protection afforded to data subjects in the UK (and in Europe) is much diminished. First to

Read article

Data Protection Act 2018 helps employers to resist subject access requests from employees

The Data Protection Act 2018 (“DPA2018”) contains three provisions that allow an employer to resist subject access requests from employees; this will undoubtedly make life easier for employers when dealing with such requests. I also make comments on the shifting balance (in favour of non-disclosure of personal data) when information about another individual is present in requested personal data. The context of this blog is processing personal data for Human Resources purposes, but clearly it has wider application. Disciplinary investigations

Read article
Search Hawktalk blogs by month :
Select Date
View blogs by category:
Hawktalk Taxonomy