Category: News

ECJ bombshell! No fair processing notice? No processing.

I think the European Court of Justice (ECJ) has just issued a judgement which has the potential to be more important than Max Schrems v Facebook (due on October 6 next week). The ECJ has just concluded that Articles 10, 11 (the fair processing requirements of Directive 95/45/EC) and Article 13 (includes the exemptions from the need to provide a fair processing notice) must be interpreted as precluding national measures which allow a public administrative body in a Member State to disclose

Read article

Government fragments data protection policy & leaves Leveson’s data protection recommendations to rot

The transfer of responsibility for data protection policy to the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) from the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) is a really bad idea.  It fragments responsibility for data protection policy across three Departments of State and risks reducing the protection afforded to data subjects.  Important data protection recommendations from Leveson will be shelved.  This blog explains why. One reason for the shift of responsibility to the DCMS (unexplained at the moment) could be because it

Read article

Voting for Jeremy? Labour Party’s vetting ensures approved voters score low Marx

A Labour spokesman has just told the BBC that the Party was confident "the processes of verification and handling applications (to vote in the leadership election) are compliant with the Data Protection Act". I will leave readers to judge this issue as I have just received an email from a colleague whose application to vote in the forthcoming Labour Party Leadership election has been rejected. The letter he received reads as follows: Dear Applicant, Thank you for your recent application

Read article

Council’s exceptions from the Data Protection Regulation degrade the privacy protection below Directive 95/46/EC

This blog explains, in detail, how the Council of Minister’s text of the Regulation, in particular the exceptions specified in Article 21 (A.21) and the flexibility granted to Member States to enact variations to the obligations under the Regulation,  are very likely to result in a level of data protection below the standard established by Directive 95/46/EC. Given that the relevant parts of the Regulation (e.g. the exceptions in A.21) are being considered in current Trilog discussions, the blog provides a link

Read article

EDPS warns that data processing under the Regulation “must be both lawful and justified”

I wasn’t going to publish this blog until I saw the above headline from the European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS) recommendations for the Data Protection Regulation (see references). This headline reads: “All data processing must be both lawful and justified”. This issue has been a concern of mine for sometime but I had convinced myself that my concerns were misplaced.  However as the EDPS has raised them, I think it is worth resurrecting the point for consumption by the data

Read article

ICO warning: “enforced subject access” used by insurance industry is an abuse of data subject rights

The Information Commissioner (ICO) has told the Association of British Insurers (ABI) that their members who ask data subjects to exercise their rights of access to health records in order to obtain insurance products are making several breaches of the Data Protection Act. Clearly, the ICO is expecting the ABI's variant of enforced subject access to cease; the only remaining question is whether the Insurance Industry disagrees and wants to “have its day in court”. In a letter to the ABI (see references),

Read article

Council of Ministers’ Regulation text negates ECJ rulings in Lindqvist and Ryneš

Note added: 21/12/2015 after GDPR Trilog text published: Article 2b of the consolidated text states that the domestic purpose is processing “by a natural person in the course of a purely personal or household activity”; Recital 15 of that text allows for limited social media use. I therefore expect that Lindqvist and Ryneš rulings to remain relevant to the GDPR Original posting The Lindqvist decision of the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in 2003 has always caused problems.  In Data

Read article

Can the Information Commissioner assess relevance, retention and unlawful processing at GCHQ?

Whilst awaiting the arrival of another enthralling, multi-megabyte, download about the General Data Protection Regulation, I started reading the judgement (Case Number IPT 14/85/CH), delivered by the Investigatory Powers Tribunal last February.  This is one of the cases between Privacy International and Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ) which identified some unlawful processing of personal data by the latter (see references). Paragraph 109 of this Tribunal’s judgment refers to the National Security Certificates established by Section 28 of the DPA;  it states:

Read article

Harmony? What harmony! Disharmony extends to one-third of the Data Protection Regulation

The final version of the European Data Protection Regulation (Council of Ministers text) is now published (on June 15). The official version however does not contain the 649 paragraphs of scrutiny reservations which shows the degree of disagreement between Member States; I have made both available (see references). In summary, the Council of Ministers' version of the Regulation contains many carve outs for Member States; it would allow them to implement the data protection legislation with a considerable degree of “flexibility”.   Such Member State flexibility can be

Read article

What can my organisation do to prepare for the Data Protection Regulation?

Since January 2012, a spectre has been haunting Europe; the spectre of the European Commission’s Data Protection Regulation.  Now the legislative finishing post is in sight and the timetable for the final set of discussions set (see references), what can data controllers and data processors do to prepare? As I am speaking on this subject at the forthcoming Data Protection Forum/NADPO meeting in London (on Friday), I thought it would be useful if I wrote the main points up. The

Read article
Search Hawktalk blogs by month :
Select Date
View blogs by category:
Hawktalk Taxonomy